I read Brian's original post - which said, in a nutshell, that voting for Bush in 2004 was the only way to preserve democracy - but just didn't feel it was necessary to respond. With his follow-up, though, I'm roused.
All I will do is point out that there is broad agreement - across party and independent lines - that we do need to succeed in Iraq. Personally I will vote for any Democrat over Bush who does not advocate withdrawal from Iraq.
Brian simply equates Bush with strength and security and wisdom. This is false. I don't see a President's Administration as credible on security if they abuse the military by denying them benefits. Or wage war on false pretenses (it was never about WMD). Or deliberately expose an undercover CIA agent solely for political payback. Or abandon the multilateral agreements of the community of nations that we need to make sure we are all in this together.
The administration we have now puts politics first, and then assumes what is good for the Party is good for America (the party that really matters, anyway). The administration we have now thinks that the only valid route to solving the foreign policy problems in a unilaeral pax Americana approach. The administration we have now sees civil liberties as an inconvenience. The administration we have now thinks that rhetoric about govt spending and taxcut ideology are sufficient replacements for fiscal responsibility to future generations.
All these things mean that the Administration we have now must be removed if we are to survive as a nation, with our ideals and liberties, intact - and if we are to remain capable of helping the world help itself.
Monday, October 6, 2003
Saturday, October 4, 2003
sweet home, Alabama
via Mac "War Liberal" Thomason - here's some follow-up on the Alabama budget after the defeat of Gov. Riley's tax plan. The result is draconian cuts in basic services that are guaranteed to disintegrate the middle class, threaten public health, undermine education, and ultimately result in a low-skilled, unproductive workforce. All said and done, Alabama will be returning to the 19th Century.
9/13/03: Proposed cuts in Birmingham.
9/13/03: Proposed cuts in State agencies.
Mac comments:
9/14/03: Schools see 4-day week as real option
9/22: Services for the poor in trouble
9/26/03: Both budgets sent to governor
Mac comments:
9/28/03: Budget cuts likely to trim trooper miles
Mac comments:
10/03/03: Courts will cut staffs one-third
click here for all of Mac's Alabama-related posts. There's more, much more...
9/13/03: Proposed cuts in Birmingham.
9/13/03: Proposed cuts in State agencies.
Mac comments:
Congratulations to the "Tax Accountability" folks for taking down such nefarious organizations as the Alabama Shakespeare Festival and rural fire departments! And those sickle cell anemia victims really had it coming, didn't they? And the National Guard scholarships -- if they're so important, let private industry take care of it!
I can go on. And I shall. How about East Alabama Emergency Medical Services, North Alabama Emergency Medical Services, Southeast Alabama Emergency Medical Services, and West Alabama Emergency Medical Services? All cut! So was the Defibrillators for Cardiac Arrest Survivors Commission. Lots of diseases, in addition to sickle cell. Money for HIV, for Parkinsons', osteoporosis, kidney disease, blindness, cystic fibrosis, brain tumors. Remember: ALFA is objectively pro-brain tumor.
9/14/03: Schools see 4-day week as real option
"I think it's all very real, and I think we'll see the four-day week put on the table in March along with a lot of other things," said Dr. Mary Jane Caylor, who represents North Alabama on the state school board.
The state Department of Education will manage this school year by trimming $100 million for textbooks, library upgrades, computers, teacher training and classroom supplies. But next year, school systems could be forced to cut extracurricular activities, expand class sizes, and even consolidate entire school systems, Caylor said.
The state may not even open school until October for the 2004-2005 school year, she predicted.
9/22: Services for the poor in trouble
Lawmakers are having to cut $66.8 million, 5.25 percent, from the state's $1.2 billion General Fund to keep a balanced budget. The cuts, which will be debated when the Legislature returns to Montgomery today, are digging deep into the state's health and human services programs. Also on the chopping block, according to budget hearings, are: life-saving drugs to 100 AIDS patients; 3,000 subsidized day-care slots to low-income families; flu shots at county health clinics; the frequency of restaurant health inspections; and a state hypertension drug program for low-income people.
9/26/03: Both budgets sent to governor
Mac comments:
There are two separate budgets: an education budget and an operating budget that covers everything else. Riley sent the operating budget back suggesting minor changes; the House approved but the Senate had gone home for the day. The final versions should pass and be signed today.
Relatively little will be cut from the education budget: .25 of a percent. (Next year will be the big cut. The operating budget was slashed, more than five percent gone.
9/28/03: Budget cuts likely to trim trooper miles
Mac comments:
Alabama state troopers are going to be limited to 150 miles a day. There are only 300 troopers on patrol.
10/03/03: Courts will cut staffs one-third
The state plans to lay off 450 to 500 of its 1,600 judicial employees statewide by Nov. 28, including bailiffs, law clerks and others.
...
David Williams, the AOC public information officer, said all bailiffs statewide and entire staffs in court administrator offices would be cut. A court administrator in each office will stay on the job. Such offices help manage jury trials and send out summonses. The office in Jefferson County is called the jury management office.
...
Williams said the only way to comply with reductions in the state budget - the AOC is some $12 million short - was to cut people from a system that is 95 percent personnel.
click here for all of Mac's Alabama-related posts. There's more, much more...
Friday, October 3, 2003
Shalom, Texas Lege
via Charles, the GOP refuses to accomodate Yom Kippur :
I kind of hope that the redistricting drags out to Easter. Then we can see which God the GOP really worships. Or fears, in the case of Tom Delay.
With that in mind, the House voted Thursday to adjourn until 2 p.m. Sunday for possible debate � which could go on beyond sundown � on any map approved by House-Senate conferees. House Speaker Tom Craddick said that if there is no map to be considered Sunday, the House would convene Monday.
Monday is Yom Kippur, the Jewish day of atonement that begins at sundown Sunday. For Jews, the day is marked by fasting, daylong prayers and not working.
In an attempt to avoid a conflict with Yom Kippur, Rep. Jim Dunnam, D-Waco, on Thursday asked the House to adjourn until 8 p.m. Monday, when the observance would be over.
"I'm told by some of our members on the floor that they will have to be out of here by 3 o'clock p.m. (Sunday) so they can make their arrangements to observe the holiday," Dunnam told colleagues. "And I know and you know that we wouldn't do this on Easter."
Dunnam's motion was rejected, and the House, by a 66-35 margin, then voted to convene Sunday afternoon.
Rep. Scott Hochberg, D-Houston and one of three Jews in the House, said he had informed the House leadership about the holiday conflict.
"The possibility is that I will have to either choose to not follow the teachings of my religion or not be here to vote on an important issue," Hochberg said.
"It appears that the desire for redistricting is so strong that respect for people's religious beliefs gets trampled in the process," he said.
I kind of hope that the redistricting drags out to Easter. Then we can see which God the GOP really worships. Or fears, in the case of Tom Delay.
trust and honor
Alternate Reality:
yeah, right.
What the current Administration doesn't understand is the essence of patriotism: doing what's best for the country. Loyalty to America, not to a political party. Respecting the sacrifice of career patriots like Wilson, who stayed behind in Baghdad during the first Gulf War to rescue hundreds of Americans who would have been stranded, or like Plame, who risked her life undercover in the field to track down dangerous weapons of mass destruction.
The current Administration instead chose to harm the security of the United States, as political payback.
History shall judge, but those present have a duty to accuse.
An outraged President Bush immediately demanded the names of those responsible for exposing Ms. Plame. He repeated his father's statement that 'those who betray the trust by exposing the names of our sources' are 'the most insidious of traitors.' There are limits to politics, Mr. Bush declared; Mr. Wilson's decision to go public about his mission had embarrassed him, but that was no excuse for actions that were both felonious and unpatriotic.
yeah, right.
What the current Administration doesn't understand is the essence of patriotism: doing what's best for the country. Loyalty to America, not to a political party. Respecting the sacrifice of career patriots like Wilson, who stayed behind in Baghdad during the first Gulf War to rescue hundreds of Americans who would have been stranded, or like Plame, who risked her life undercover in the field to track down dangerous weapons of mass destruction.
The current Administration instead chose to harm the security of the United States, as political payback.
History shall judge, but those present have a duty to accuse.
No Exit Strategy
I think it's essential, with the ongoing revelations of how the Bush Administration lied to the American people in order to wage war on Iraq, to address the point that Howard Dean has consistently made on the campaign trail - we cannot leave.
Kos has done an excellent job of highlighting US casualties, which puts a human face on eth sacrifice that our troops are making out of duty. That puts the Bush Administration's treatment of our troops all the more despicable. But the fact that American troops are dying (Bush Lied, people died) is NOT an argument for withdrawal! It's a condemnation of the fundamental distrust of the American people by the Administration, and a call to multilateralism and cooperation with the international community.
Many liberals and Bush opponents do not understand this essential reality. For example, Kucinich and his supporters have endless rhetoric about withdrawing US troops immediately, completely oblivious to the obvious consequences.
Steven Den Beste has an excellent essay which describes exactly why we cannot abandon Iraq as we did Afghanistan after the Cold War, that is essential reading. I urge everyone to read this essay in its entirety, but here are some relevant excerpts.
As they say, read the whole thing. That's why Dean is right - and why we are committed to Iraq, now for better or for worse.
Kos has done an excellent job of highlighting US casualties, which puts a human face on eth sacrifice that our troops are making out of duty. That puts the Bush Administration's treatment of our troops all the more despicable. But the fact that American troops are dying (Bush Lied, people died) is NOT an argument for withdrawal! It's a condemnation of the fundamental distrust of the American people by the Administration, and a call to multilateralism and cooperation with the international community.
Many liberals and Bush opponents do not understand this essential reality. For example, Kucinich and his supporters have endless rhetoric about withdrawing US troops immediately, completely oblivious to the obvious consequences.
Steven Den Beste has an excellent essay which describes exactly why we cannot abandon Iraq as we did Afghanistan after the Cold War, that is essential reading. I urge everyone to read this essay in its entirety, but here are some relevant excerpts.
If you have to pay the awful expense in blood and treasure to fight and win a war, then if you're smart you'll try to make sure you never have to fight that particular war again. A war to end all wars probably won't ever happen unless it's one which annihilates our species, but at least you can make sure that you don't have to again fight the foe you just defeated.
You don't want to do what the US did in 1991: wound a foe badly but leave him standing. And you don't want to do what the treaty of Versailles did: create a situation where there's a strong likelihood of further war later.
...
The new Iraqi government doesn't have to look like ours, but it does have to be secular and democratic, and the new constitution has to guarantee certain fundamental civil rights to the people of Iraq, including in particular the right of free speech, free press and legal equality for women.
But once that's in place, if we then shake the hands of Iraq's new moderate leaders and go home, it could all fall apart within just a few years. In the 1930's in Germany, the Nazi party took power by winning elections within the rules of the democratic system there but then eliminated that democratic system and converted the nation to a dictatorship; extremists in Iraq might do the same. When Iraq is militarily weak after the war, hostile or ambitious neighbors might take that opportunity to invade. If Iraq builds up a military force to defend itself, that could in turn be seen as a threat by other nations there, especially smaller ones like Kuwait. Any of those could lead to war; all of them represent long term failure.
That's why we can't leave. We had to occupy both Japan and Germany for decades, and we're going to have to do the same in Iraq. In a year or two or five, whenever enough progress has been made to permit it, a new constitution will be put into place and the Iraqis will elect their own government, and we'll turn power over to them. But we will need to keep a substantial military force there afterwards for the foreseeable future, on the order of 30 years.
...
By their presence, our troops will say that the US guarantees that Iraq will remain peaceful, liberal, and democratic, because anyone who says otherwise will have to answer to us. Any threat of invasion by Syria, Turkey or Iran would face our troops and our air power, with all that implies. Iraq will eventually have an army and an air force but it will be far smaller than the one Saddam created, and we'll guarantee that it won't be used by Iraq to invade any other nation or oppress any minority group inside Iraq. And we will guarantee that Iraq's government never comes under the control of extremists who would then scrap the constitution and once again institute a brutal autocracy.
As they say, read the whole thing. That's why Dean is right - and why we are committed to Iraq, now for better or for worse.
Thursday, October 2, 2003
bylines at TAPPED as impetus for blogroll change
with the addition of bylines at TAPPED, I imagine that Matthew Yglesias will be posting even more frequently. It's time to drop Matt's original and venerable blog from my blogroll - it's safe to assume that his creative energies are going to be focused on TAPPED for the time being, so that's where I'm going to go for my Yglesian wisdom henceforth.
Also welcome my friend Jason Stafford to the blogsphere, at his new blog, Demented Fantasia. The UNMEDIA blogroll nepotism policy remains active as a filter on reciprocation requests, so please don't bother. But do head over to Jason's blog and encourage him to post his contrarian, conservative, libertarian GOP card carrier views with high frequency!
And, welcome Jen Hayward back to the Blogsphere - her new TypePad blog Palace by the Sea obsoletes her original blogspot-hosted Umbrella Noir. Jen is the sweetest soul in the universe, and she's ten times the writer that I am - she almost approaches Zahra-Lileks status for compelling personal prose.
Also welcome my friend Jason Stafford to the blogsphere, at his new blog, Demented Fantasia. The UNMEDIA blogroll nepotism policy remains active as a filter on reciprocation requests, so please don't bother. But do head over to Jason's blog and encourage him to post his contrarian, conservative, libertarian GOP card carrier views with high frequency!
And, welcome Jen Hayward back to the Blogsphere - her new TypePad blog Palace by the Sea obsoletes her original blogspot-hosted Umbrella Noir. Jen is the sweetest soul in the universe, and she's ten times the writer that I am - she almost approaches Zahra-Lileks status for compelling personal prose.
conflicts of interest
Remember that 12-hour advance warning that the Justice Department gave the White House rearding preserving documents related to the Plame Affair?
(emphasis mine). That's 8:46 AM Tuesday morning. This is outrageous - Nina Totenberg mentioned this on NPR noting that the 12-hour gift has not gone un-noticed:
Well, I think we know why. And the calls for a special prosecutor are increasing - including an overwhelming majority of the public polled on the issue:
Interestingly, Timothy Noah argues that a special prosecutor is not necessary:
I disagree, since even if the special prosecutor serves at the whim of the AG, they still have an additional layer of insulation (the "special" status) in the public eye that will help shield the investigation from interference. As Noah points out, when Nixon fired special prosecutor Archibald Cox, his replacement simply picked right up where he left off. Firing a special prosecutor is a publicity-garnering event, so there's correspondingly more attention paid to the conduct of teh White House and the tone of its cooperation than if the entire investigation was handled internally.
We need a special propsecutor, and even a majority of Republicans polled agree. Anyone who argues otherwise is playing the partisan game and this time it isn't pork, but national security that lies at stake.
With pressure building, the Justice Department alerted the White House late Monday of the decision to move from a preliminary inquiry into a full investigation, a step rarely taken with complaints involving leaks of classified information.
...
Most White House employees discovered the probe was under way when they turned on their computers and found an e-mail timed at 8:46 a.m. that said: PLEASE READ: Important Message From Counsel's Office. It alerted the staff to keep all documents that could be related to the investigation.
(emphasis mine). That's 8:46 AM Tuesday morning. This is outrageous - Nina Totenberg mentioned this on NPR noting that the 12-hour gift has not gone un-noticed:
"The White house asked for and got permission earlier this week to wait a day before issuing a directive to preserve all documents and logs which led one seasoned federal prosecutor to wonder why they wanted to wait a day, and who at the justice department told them they could do that, and why?"
Well, I think we know why. And the calls for a special prosecutor are increasing - including an overwhelming majority of the public polled on the issue:
Seven in 10 Americans, including a majority of Republicans, say they favor a special counsel rather than the administration's own Justice Department to investigate the leak of a CIA undercover officer's identity, according to an ABC-Washington Post poll.
Interestingly, Timothy Noah argues that a special prosecutor is not necessary:
many Democrats are calling for the appointment of a special prosecutor. Chatterbox isn't sure even that is worth the bother. Special prosecutors serve at the pleasure of the attorney general, making them the practical equivalent of a Justice Department employee. Why not just give it to the employee? Justice Department lifers, no less than special or independent counsels, have the ability to retaliate against politically motivated suppression of their investigation by leaking to the press.
I disagree, since even if the special prosecutor serves at the whim of the AG, they still have an additional layer of insulation (the "special" status) in the public eye that will help shield the investigation from interference. As Noah points out, when Nixon fired special prosecutor Archibald Cox, his replacement simply picked right up where he left off. Firing a special prosecutor is a publicity-garnering event, so there's correspondingly more attention paid to the conduct of teh White House and the tone of its cooperation than if the entire investigation was handled internally.
We need a special propsecutor, and even a majority of Republicans polled agree. Anyone who argues otherwise is playing the partisan game and this time it isn't pork, but national security that lies at stake.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)