Friday, October 3, 2003

Shalom, Texas Lege

via Charles, the GOP refuses to accomodate Yom Kippur :



With that in mind, the House voted Thursday to adjourn until 2 p.m. Sunday for possible debate � which could go on beyond sundown � on any map approved by House-Senate conferees. House Speaker Tom Craddick said that if there is no map to be considered Sunday, the House would convene Monday.



Monday is Yom Kippur, the Jewish day of atonement that begins at sundown Sunday. For Jews, the day is marked by fasting, daylong prayers and not working.



In an attempt to avoid a conflict with Yom Kippur, Rep. Jim Dunnam, D-Waco, on Thursday asked the House to adjourn until 8 p.m. Monday, when the observance would be over.



"I'm told by some of our members on the floor that they will have to be out of here by 3 o'clock p.m. (Sunday) so they can make their arrangements to observe the holiday," Dunnam told colleagues. "And I know and you know that we wouldn't do this on Easter."



Dunnam's motion was rejected, and the House, by a 66-35 margin, then voted to convene Sunday afternoon.



Rep. Scott Hochberg, D-Houston and one of three Jews in the House, said he had informed the House leadership about the holiday conflict.



"The possibility is that I will have to either choose to not follow the teachings of my religion or not be here to vote on an important issue," Hochberg said.



"It appears that the desire for redistricting is so strong that respect for people's religious beliefs gets trampled in the process," he said.




I kind of hope that the redistricting drags out to Easter. Then we can see which God the GOP really worships. Or fears, in the case of Tom Delay.

trust and honor

Alternate Reality:



An outraged President Bush immediately demanded the names of those responsible for exposing Ms. Plame. He repeated his father's statement that 'those who betray the trust by exposing the names of our sources' are 'the most insidious of traitors.' There are limits to politics, Mr. Bush declared; Mr. Wilson's decision to go public about his mission had embarrassed him, but that was no excuse for actions that were both felonious and unpatriotic.




yeah, right.



What the current Administration doesn't understand is the essence of patriotism: doing what's best for the country. Loyalty to America, not to a political party. Respecting the sacrifice of career patriots like Wilson, who stayed behind in Baghdad during the first Gulf War to rescue hundreds of Americans who would have been stranded, or like Plame, who risked her life undercover in the field to track down dangerous weapons of mass destruction.



The current Administration instead chose to harm the security of the United States, as political payback.



History shall judge, but those present have a duty to accuse.

No Exit Strategy

I think it's essential, with the ongoing revelations of how the Bush Administration lied to the American people in order to wage war on Iraq, to address the point that Howard Dean has consistently made on the campaign trail - we cannot leave.



Kos has done an excellent job of highlighting US casualties, which puts a human face on eth sacrifice that our troops are making out of duty. That puts the Bush Administration's treatment of our troops all the more despicable. But the fact that American troops are dying (Bush Lied, people died) is NOT an argument for withdrawal! It's a condemnation of the fundamental distrust of the American people by the Administration, and a call to multilateralism and cooperation with the international community.



Many liberals and Bush opponents do not understand this essential reality. For example, Kucinich and his supporters have endless rhetoric about withdrawing US troops immediately, completely oblivious to the obvious consequences.



Steven Den Beste has an excellent essay which describes exactly why we cannot abandon Iraq as we did Afghanistan after the Cold War, that is essential reading. I urge everyone to read this essay in its entirety, but here are some relevant excerpts.



If you have to pay the awful expense in blood and treasure to fight and win a war, then if you're smart you'll try to make sure you never have to fight that particular war again. A war to end all wars probably won't ever happen unless it's one which annihilates our species, but at least you can make sure that you don't have to again fight the foe you just defeated.



You don't want to do what the US did in 1991: wound a foe badly but leave him standing. And you don't want to do what the treaty of Versailles did: create a situation where there's a strong likelihood of further war later.

...

The new Iraqi government doesn't have to look like ours, but it does have to be secular and democratic, and the new constitution has to guarantee certain fundamental civil rights to the people of Iraq, including in particular the right of free speech, free press and legal equality for women.



But once that's in place, if we then shake the hands of Iraq's new moderate leaders and go home, it could all fall apart within just a few years. In the 1930's in Germany, the Nazi party took power by winning elections within the rules of the democratic system there but then eliminated that democratic system and converted the nation to a dictatorship; extremists in Iraq might do the same. When Iraq is militarily weak after the war, hostile or ambitious neighbors might take that opportunity to invade. If Iraq builds up a military force to defend itself, that could in turn be seen as a threat by other nations there, especially smaller ones like Kuwait. Any of those could lead to war; all of them represent long term failure.



That's why we can't leave. We had to occupy both Japan and Germany for decades, and we're going to have to do the same in Iraq. In a year or two or five, whenever enough progress has been made to permit it, a new constitution will be put into place and the Iraqis will elect their own government, and we'll turn power over to them. But we will need to keep a substantial military force there afterwards for the foreseeable future, on the order of 30 years.

...

By their presence, our troops will say that the US guarantees that Iraq will remain peaceful, liberal, and democratic, because anyone who says otherwise will have to answer to us. Any threat of invasion by Syria, Turkey or Iran would face our troops and our air power, with all that implies. Iraq will eventually have an army and an air force but it will be far smaller than the one Saddam created, and we'll guarantee that it won't be used by Iraq to invade any other nation or oppress any minority group inside Iraq. And we will guarantee that Iraq's government never comes under the control of extremists who would then scrap the constitution and once again institute a brutal autocracy.




As they say, read the whole thing. That's why Dean is right - and why we are committed to Iraq, now for better or for worse.

Thursday, October 2, 2003

bylines at TAPPED as impetus for blogroll change

with the addition of bylines at TAPPED, I imagine that Matthew Yglesias will be posting even more frequently. It's time to drop Matt's original and venerable blog from my blogroll - it's safe to assume that his creative energies are going to be focused on TAPPED for the time being, so that's where I'm going to go for my Yglesian wisdom henceforth.



Also welcome my friend Jason Stafford to the blogsphere, at his new blog, Demented Fantasia. The UNMEDIA blogroll nepotism policy remains active as a filter on reciprocation requests, so please don't bother. But do head over to Jason's blog and encourage him to post his contrarian, conservative, libertarian GOP card carrier views with high frequency!



And, welcome Jen Hayward back to the Blogsphere - her new TypePad blog Palace by the Sea obsoletes her original blogspot-hosted Umbrella Noir. Jen is the sweetest soul in the universe, and she's ten times the writer that I am - she almost approaches Zahra-Lileks status for compelling personal prose.

conflicts of interest

Remember that 12-hour advance warning that the Justice Department gave the White House rearding preserving documents related to the Plame Affair?



With pressure building, the Justice Department alerted the White House late Monday of the decision to move from a preliminary inquiry into a full investigation, a step rarely taken with complaints involving leaks of classified information.

...

Most White House employees discovered the probe was under way when they turned on their computers and found an e-mail timed at 8:46 a.m. that said: PLEASE READ: Important Message From Counsel's Office. It alerted the staff to keep all documents that could be related to the investigation.




(emphasis mine). That's 8:46 AM Tuesday morning. This is outrageous - Nina Totenberg mentioned this on NPR noting that the 12-hour gift has not gone un-noticed:



"The White house asked for and got permission earlier this week to wait a day before issuing a directive to preserve all documents and logs which led one seasoned federal prosecutor to wonder why they wanted to wait a day, and who at the justice department told them they could do that, and why?"




Well, I think we know why. And the calls for a special prosecutor are increasing - including an overwhelming majority of the public polled on the issue:



Seven in 10 Americans, including a majority of Republicans, say they favor a special counsel rather than the administration's own Justice Department to investigate the leak of a CIA undercover officer's identity, according to an ABC-Washington Post poll.




Interestingly, Timothy Noah argues that a special prosecutor is not necessary:



many Democrats are calling for the appointment of a special prosecutor. Chatterbox isn't sure even that is worth the bother. Special prosecutors serve at the pleasure of the attorney general, making them the practical equivalent of a Justice Department employee. Why not just give it to the employee? Justice Department lifers, no less than special or independent counsels, have the ability to retaliate against politically motivated suppression of their investigation by leaking to the press.




I disagree, since even if the special prosecutor serves at the whim of the AG, they still have an additional layer of insulation (the "special" status) in the public eye that will help shield the investigation from interference. As Noah points out, when Nixon fired special prosecutor Archibald Cox, his replacement simply picked right up where he left off. Firing a special prosecutor is a publicity-garnering event, so there's correspondingly more attention paid to the conduct of teh White House and the tone of its cooperation than if the entire investigation was handled internally.



We need a special propsecutor, and even a majority of Republicans polled agree. Anyone who argues otherwise is playing the partisan game and this time it isn't pork, but national security that lies at stake.

Wednesday, October 1, 2003

changing the subject

Glenn says that we should "forget" the Plame issue, because the "real" story is Joe Wilson:



Forget Valerie Plame, the big scandal is why anyone in the Bush Administration would ever have tasked a guy with Wilson's views[1] with an important mission... Regardless of the rest of the story, heads should roll for that.




Look, I understand that some people believe that the war on Iraq was justified and that anyone espousing a different view is fundamentally wrong. I happen to have almost the precise view. And at least people who disagree on this can agree with (for example) Howard Dean that having invaded Iraq, we have to succeed there. So I respect Glenn's view and am able to agree with him on the far more important issue of what we do now despite our disagreement on how we got to this point.



But claiming that Wilson's views about Iraq are even relevant to the Plame affair - let alone being more important - is ultimately tantamount to Bush apologism. Unwitting, perhaps, but apologism just the same, because it simply helps the Administration political partisans fan smoke to cover their tracks. It's like a Clintonista talking about blowjobs instead of perjury.[2]



Note that the conflict of interest of having Justice investigate the White House leak has already materialized to the detriment of the public interest, by giving the perpetrators a 12-hour advance warning in which the criminal leakers could conceivably have destroyed documents:



The [Justice] department notified Gonzales about 8:30 p.m. Monday that it was launching an investigation but said he could wait until the next morning to notify staff and direct them to preserve relevant material, McClellan said.





I think it's simply wrong to try and shift the issue from who outed Plame, who we know to have been an actual CIA undercover operative specializing in finding hidden weapons of mass destruction, to a political attack on Wilson's credibility. It's unrelated to the actual crime that has occurred.



Still, just for the record, I will address Glenn's statements that the "real scandal" is Wilson's views. Why would someone with Wilson's views be assigned to such an important mission?



Well, the Post reports that he had a significant (and unimpeachable) sponsor:



This toughness impressed President George H.W. Bush, who called Wilson a "truly inspiring" diplomat who exhibited "courageous leadership" by facing down Hussein and helping to gain freedom for the Americans before the 1991 war began.




Also, note that during the previous Bush presidency, Ambassador Wilson served in Baghdad as Deputy Chief of Mission at the U.S. Embassy. During Operation Desert Shield he was the acting Ambassador negoitiated the release of several hundred American hostages. He was a member of the U.S. Diplomatic Service from 1976 until 1998His African assignments include Niamey, Niger, 1976-1978; Lome, Togo, 1978-79; the State Department Bureau of African Affairs, 1979-1981; and Pretoria, South Africa, 1981-1982.



The man was qualified. Finally, for a detailed account of what Wilson actually did in Niger to investigate the claim, read the TPM interview and judge for yourself.



[1] Glenn links to Bill Hobbs, who tries to argue Wilson is lying when he claims he has an apolitical interest in the issue of Iraqi uranium. Hobbs makes a number of critiques of Wilson's statements, but all of these are for his policy opinoins on the Iraq war, drawn from his own experience and contacts. He doesn't attack the GOP, or President Bush, or argue a partisan case here in any way. He strongly critiques the Administration for its policy. This is the very essence of being apolitical - focusing on policy, not on partisanship.

[2] Comparisons to other Presidential scandals are of course currency of the realm. But it's worth noting that the head of the RNC has rightfully conceded that if there is truth to the Plame affair, it's far more serious a matter than Watergate.:



Hardball (MSNBC - 9/30/03):



CHRIS MATTHEWS: Don't you think it's more serious than Watergate, when you think about it?



RNC CHAIRMAN ED GILLESPIE: I think if the allegation is true, to reveal the identity of an undercover CIA operative -- it's abhorrent, and it should be a crime, and it is a crime.



CHRIS MATTHEWS: It'd be worse than Watergate, wouldn't it?



GILLESPIE: It's -- Yeah, I suppose in terms of the real world implications of it. It's not just politics




That's why I am not using the tired -gate suffix but calling it the Plame Affair in its own right.

Bush dodges the Plame issue

The transcript of Bush's remarks about the Plame affair reveals that Bush seems to be operating from talkig points, and not addressing the substance or the seriousness of the scandal. As Josh Marshall of TPM points out:



There's no mention of blowing the cover of a CIA covert operative, no mention of Wilson, the issue of retaliation, or anything like that.



His repeated mantra is his opposition to "leaks of classified information." That of course is a much broader issue and, not coincidentally, a charge that the White House has previously levelled at Congress.



They're trying to move the subject on to much more comfortable ground and push the whole controversy over into the long and muddled history of leaks of classified information.



The law which seems to have been violated, of course, is a different one. And this allows the president to sidestep entirely the issue of his staffers retaliating against a critic by ruining his wife's career.




not to mention the serious threat to National Security. Cue Kevin Drum:



The fact that administration officials took it upon themselves to expose a CIA agent shows appalling judgment. They didn't know whether or not that endangered any CIA operations, which is why you just don't do this. And the fact that they did it for such base (and trivial) reasons says a lot about the kind of people they are.



But beyond that, of course the fundamental issue here is that � especially in a post-9/11 world � you don't play games with national security. Regardless of whether blowing Plame's network caused any serious problems, this is the reason the CIA is fighting back so hard on this: because they want to make sure no one ever does it again. Next time it might get a city full of people killed.



So: this affair exposes bad character and high school freshman levels of poor judgment among allegedly senior officials. But it also betrays a lack of seriousness about national security at a time when national security should be the most important thing they're thinking about.